Welcome to the charming world of Sugar Pine Coffee & Creamery (Millie’s), nestled in the scenic Graeagle, California. This delightful coffee shop and ice cream parlor is a hidden gem at 7512 CA-89, inviting all who enter with the rich aromas of freshly brewed coffee and the sweet allure of homemade confections. With its warm atmosphere and attentive staff, including the ever-friendly Peggy, it's no wonder why locals and visitors alike have fallen in love with this quaint establishment.
Sugar Pine offers more than just a caffeine fix. The reviews resonate with joy, highlighting not only the exceptional coffee but also the delectable homemade chocolates. Kristen Frasure shares her enthusiasm for the "great coffee" and the kindness of the staff, making every visit feel special. The menu features an enticing selection of flavored coffees, such as the beloved pumpkin pie iced latte and the rich iced mocha, as praised by Taryn Boisvert.
The creamery side of Millie’s shines brightly, offering a range of delectable ice creams. While flavors like Moose Tracks tantalize with creamy goodness, some guests have noted a slightly elevated price point for ice cream—putting a slight dent in the experience, but surely not diminishing the quality. The view from the establishment, as appreciated by visitors, offers a picturesque backdrop to savor your treats. Britt Senecal particularly adored the breakfast options, suggesting that early risers can indulge in visually delightful items like breakfast burritos and cinnamon rolls, alongside a rich cup of coffee.
Millie’s doesn't just cater to your taste buds; it also embraces a sense of community and efficiency, especially during busy events. Kris Lahti praised the staff's ability to manage the crowds while maintaining personal care for each customer, illustrating their commitment to service. This balance of quality and efficiency is what makes Sugar Pine a cherished local haunt.
In essence, Sugar Pine Coffee & Creamery promises an experience that goes beyond just coffee and ice cream. It’s about feeling at home in a cozy atmosphere with friendly faces, indulging in exceptional flavors, and creating delightful memories. So, whether you're stopping by for a quick caffeine boost, a refreshing ice cream, or a leisurely breakfast, Millie’s is the perfect stop in the heart of Graeagle.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Kristen Frasure
14/10/2025
My husband and I love this place! Peggy and the rest of the staff are always so kind. Great coffee and homemade chocolates- we highly recommend!
Taryn Boisvert
30/09/2025
We just loved this coffee and ice cream shop! Delicious pumpkin pie iced latte and iced mocha! Friendly staff!
Britt Senecal
29/09/2025
An adorable little coffee shop/creamery. If you get there early enough you can get the breakfast burritos and cinnamon rolls . It was a visual and tasty delight. I absolutely loved the vibes.
Leah C
21/09/2025
Moose tracks was creamy. Hard to mess up ice cream, and it was a bit expensive. The single scoop was 4.75. The worker was not overly friendly and the music was very loud. View is lovely.
Kris Lahti
19/09/2025
Wow! I love this place. I've been here many times over the years, and was here twice since July 5. *You all were so efficiently taken care of all of us, and getting us in and out on July 5 with the craft fair at the park. Thanks for making that happen! *Of course, we love checking out the mugs and items that you have for sale - so cute! *Everyone working behind the counter was careful to get exactly what each person wanted, and at the same time move efficiently to get us through. *And the quality of your ice cream is so excellent! I noticed the brand advertisement on the front door, but did not take a picture, thinking I could get it off the website. I would love to know the brand of your ice cream. *****Absolutely Excellent. In every way.
Sarah Zaki
23/07/2025
Peggy and all the helpers at the cafe are so wonderful! They are always so friendly right when I walk in the door, and their lattes are delicious. I recently tried their ice cream too and will definitely be back for more. Their outdoor seating area is so charming too. Peggy catered an event for us with donuts and coffee, and she was so pleasant and professional to work with. I’m looking forward to supporting this business any time I can!
Stephanie Brannen
07/07/2025
Absolutely loved this place. Everything about it! The coffee, the food and the atmosphere. I got a honey latte and a blueberry muffin, both were so good!!! Also outside sitting was great